QuickBooks Online integrations / Compare

Lightyear vs Relay for QuickBooks Online

Where do they differ?

Side by side

LightyearRelay
Invoices-Two-way
Payments-To QuickBooks Online
Bank transactions-To QuickBooks Online
BillsTo QuickBooks OnlineFrom QuickBooks Online
ContactsFrom QuickBooks OnlineTwo-way
Tax ratesFrom QuickBooks OnlineTo QuickBooks Online
Classes and locationsFrom QuickBooks OnlineYes
Chart of accountsFrom QuickBooks OnlineFrom QuickBooks Online
AttachmentsTo QuickBooks OnlineTwo-way
Price from (USD)US$199
Essentials: per month for 125 credits, 30-day rolling contract
Free
Starter: Bank feed to QuickBooks on all plans; QuickBooks Bill Pay needs Grow or Scale, not Starter
Price from (GBP)–Free
Price from (AUD)–Free
RegionsNo regional restriction statedNo regional restriction stated
Minimum QuickBooks Online planunknownunknown
Known limitations
Purchase order numbers are not sent, because the QuickBooks API does not allow it minor
Supplier credit notes arrive in QuickBooks as bills, not vendor credits. minor
Suppliers, GL codes, tax rates and classes/locations don't refresh by themselves; new or changed QuickBooks records need a manual Import. minor
Exports fail for bills dated in a closed QuickBooks period, or when the bill's currency differs from the QuickBooks supplier's currency. minor
Card transactions do not come through the bank feed and need the separate card connection minor
Edits, sends and paid status changes made in QuickBooks do not sync to Relay Invoices minor
QuickBooks Online for Bill Pay (bill and vendor import, payment sync) needs the Grow or Scale plan; it is not on the free Starter plan. moderate
Expense Management transactions only reach QuickBooks when you push them; nothing moves automatically. minor
Partial bill payments are not yet supported, and marking an imported bill paid in QuickBooks breaks its sync. minor
Only settled transactions reach QuickBooks; pending items and account name changes don't sync. minor
Bills uploaded directly into Relay must be in USD. minor
Vendor statusListedListed
Facts verified18 Nov 202618 Nov 2026

Which should you choose?

Built only from the facts above. Neither app is ranked overall: each list names the situations where the sourced facts favour it.

Choose Lightyear when…

The facts we have don't show a clear reason to prefer Lightyear over Relay. Use the differences above and the points to check below.

Choose Relay when…

Check before buying either

No winner is declared: which is better depends on what you need. Every fact links to its sources on each app's page.