Shopify integrations / Compare
Recurly Commerce vs Stripe for Shopify
Where do they differ?
Both apps document the same things in the same way. The differences are in price, regions and setup below.
Side by side
| Recurly Commerce | Stripe | |
|---|---|---|
| Orders | To Shopify | - |
| Products | - | Yes |
| Customers | - | Yes |
| Fulfilments | No | - |
| Discounts | Yes | Yes |
| Refunds | No | - |
| Price from (USD) | Usage fees | Usage fees |
| Regions | No regional restriction stated | No regional restriction stated |
| Minimum Shopify plan | unknown | any plan that supports apps |
| Known limitations | Recurly Commerce does not handle fulfilment or refunds: both must be done in Shopify. minor Renewals are processed through Shopify Payments, and activating a plan needs the Shopify 'Approve app charges' permission. minor Only subscription orders are tagged in Shopify; one-time purchase orders stay untagged. minor | The main synced object is the subscription (Shopify subscription contract with Stripe subscription), which is not one of Lode's Shopify objects, so it is not listed in the sync rows above. minor Smart Retries is not supported when payments are processed through Shopify's payment platform; standard retry schedules apply. Payment-failure emails for recurring orders are not sent by Shopify and need Shopify Flow or Stripe settings. moderate Custom attributes on a Shopify subscription contract are copied to Stripe only when the subscription is created; later changes are not synced. minor |
| Vendor status | Listed | Listed |
| Facts verified | 20 Nov 2026 | 20 Nov 2026 |
Which should you choose?
Built only from the facts above. Neither app is ranked overall: each list names the situations where the sourced facts favour it.
Choose Recurly Commerce when…
- you need orders synced: Recurly Commerce's sources document it, while Stripe's sources don't say either way.
Choose Stripe when…
- you need customers synced: Stripe's sources document it, while Recurly Commerce's sources don't say either way.
- you need products synced: Stripe's sources document it, while Recurly Commerce's sources don't say either way.
Check before buying either
- Stripe: Smart Retries is not supported when payments are processed through Shopify's payment platform; standard retry schedules apply. Payment-failure emails for recurring orders are not sent by Shopify and need Shopify Flow or Stripe settings.
- Recurly Commerce does not state which Shopify plan is needed. Confirm yours is supported before connecting.
- Setup time is not stated for Recurly Commerce and Stripe. Check the vendor's setup guide before you commit.
No winner is declared: which is better depends on what you need. Every fact links to its sources on each app's page.